Hello dear
Welcome to Arthur Avenue Deli
Arthur Avenue Deli, nestled in Mahopac, NY, is a quintessential Italian deli that brings the heart of New York's culinary tradition to life. With a menu full of fresh, homemade offerings—from delicious paninis like the Chicken Cutlet BLT to vibrant salads—it’s a haven for food lovers. The daily-made fresh mozzarella is a standout, highly praised by patrons. Customers rave about the exceptional service and inviting atmosphere, where friendly staff ensure a memorable dining experience. Arthur Avenue Deli isn’t just about food; it’s a cherished gathering place for community members, offering everything from catering to outdoor seating, making it a truly versatile gem.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
THE YO CUZ
Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozz, Roasted Peppers Balsamic
Grilled Chicken Cesar Salad
EGGPLANTMOZZARELLA
About
Arthur Avenue Deli
Welcome to Arthur Avenue Deli, a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Mahopac, NY. This Italian deli is not just about filling your stomach; it's an experience that takes you back to the very essence of Italian culinary tradition. Located at 926 US-6, Arthur Avenue Deli is where quality ingredients and heartfelt customer service come together to create memorable meals.
Walk through the doors, and you’re immediately enveloped in an atmosphere that boasts cleanliness and warmth—a true reflection of its authentic roots. Here, you’ll find a vast array of delicious sandwiches that range from their renowned Eggplant Mozzarella to the classic Tuna BLT. Each creation highlights fresh, premium ingredients, such as the deli's famous freshly made mozzarella, which customers rave about. One standout review mentioned the indescribable joy and satisfaction derived from their Carmel Special—an absolute must for any first-time visitor!
Besides delectable sandwiches, Arthur Avenue Deli also offers a variety of sides, including small potato salad and broccoli rabe, which beautifully complement any meal. And let's not forget about their selection of beverages, ranging from refreshing Pure Leaf Lemon Tea to nostalgic YooHoo. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or catering for a gathering, Arthur Avenue Deli has something for everyone.
What truly sets this deli apart is the dedication of its staff. Patrons have noted the exceptional service and friendliness that make each visit memorable. A customer expressed their delight in how the staff even took the time to craft a delicious Muffuletta upon request—exemplifying their willingness to go above and beyond for their guests. Stories like these are the heart of Arthur Avenue Deli, as reiterated by enthusiastic visitors who are longing to return.
In essence, Arthur Avenue Deli is not just a place to grab a meal; it’s an invitation to indulge in the experience of traditional Italian deli culture. From hearty sandwiches to delightful customer service, every element brings a taste of Italy to Mahopac. So if you find yourself in the area, do yourself a favor and visit this culinary haven—you'll leave satisfied and craving more!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The combination of exceptional food and outstanding customer service makes it an absolute gem. I recently had the pleasure of catering from them, and my friends and family are still buzzing about the delicious spread. I wholeheartedly recommend them. And by the way, the Carmel Special is my ultimate goto! ”
“ Passing through and got the Bronx boy on a hero. It was TRIPLE LAYERED with chicken cutlets. You dont see that anymore these days. Traditional classic NY Italian deli. Clean and has all the Italian goodies your nana gave you as a kid. Staff were talkative and happy to serve. If I ever find myself back in the area I will absolutely be coming here again ”
“ Honestly one of, if not the best delis in Westchester or NYC for that matter. The food is fresh, flavorful, and plain old excellent! Their service is beyond wonderful. Hell, I even asked them if they could make a muffuletta like the New Orleans Italians used to I guess still do... They looked it up and made one better than I remember them being! I cant say enough on their behalf. Theyre beyond awesome. So lucky to have found them! ”
“ Just stopped in this deli to pick up some food for my friends that live in the area they had never tried before and it was absolutely delish! I could tell when walking in it was going to be good. Clean, friendly atmosphere with specialty items for purchase. Sandwiches were so tasty, will definitely be back! ”
“ A true Italian deli with handsome Italian men running the place fresh, homemade sauces, mozzarella, pasta, bread, and of course delicious deli meats and sandwiches. What more could you ask for? You definitely want to check Arthur Ave Deli out! Youll be happy you did. ”
“ We had food catered from here for a family party. Food was delicious and everyone was so nice. Will be back! Cant wait to try a sandwich lol ”
“ Arthur Avenue Deli has moved to a new space in Mahopac. Nice large and clean store. Their sandwich are as always, delicious and on point! The Carmel special is amazing! The employees are very friendly. So glad they are still within driving distance! ”
“ Went here for the first time today and got the best panini Ive ever had. I think to call it a deli misrepresents what to expect walking in. The space is big, roomy, and meticulously kept. Everyone behind the counter was happy, friendly, and helpful. They have freezers full of every ravioli you can think of I cant wait to try mine, imported Italian groceries, ready to go options like soups and sauces, and a case full of tons of amazing looking options. I got the yo cuz panini which was absolutely incredible! They have tables and chairs so you can eat inside. I know this is a small thing but they brought the sandwiches right over to the table on beautiful dishes which was such a classy touch. The prices are incredibly fair as well. I usually go to AS because thats the best place I could find in the area. Arthur Ave deli beats them in price and quality. Do yourself a favor and give them a try thank me later. Also, dont skip the mini cannolis on the counter. Just as good as my Nonnas! ”